The British Journal of Medicine published two interesting articles this month. The first is an education review on the overdiagnosis and medicalization of athletes (and the public at large)(1). The authors cite several factors supporting this trend in sports medicine, including: The belief that more intervention improves outcomes. Making the definition of disease more inclusive.... MORE
Deltoid ligament: Not your run-of-the-mill ankle sprain
Most sportsmen sprain their ankles laterally, however, there is the rare instance of a medial ankle sprain. In today’s feature article highlighting uncommon injuries, physiotherapist Chris Mallac explores deltoid ligament injuries. How infrequent are these injuries? Researchers in Alabama conducted an epidemiological study to find out1. They reviewed a large sample of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) members through the Injury Surveillance Program (ISP) from 2009-2015.
The study sample consisted of players of 25 varsity sports whose athletic trainers (AT) reported injury data. They defined deltoid ligament injury as one occurring during collegiate sports play or practice, and requiring consultation or treatment from either the AT or a physician. Injuries to the deltoid ligament occurred in this population – athletes from 25 different sports – during this time period, at a rate of 0.79/10,000 athletic exposures. This means that an athlete has to actually participate in the sport – in either practice or competition – more than 10,000 times to have a chance of spraining his deltoid ligament. When examining sports specific injuries, the rates of deltoid sprain in men’s football, women’s gymnastics, and men and women’s soccer and basketball, were higher than the overall rates.
Roughly half (49.7%) of all recorded injuries in the study occurred due to player-to-player contact. A little more than one third of the injuries (39.5%) were mild with no time lost in sport, and only 6.6% were severe. As expected due to the high rate of contact injuries, more players injured their deltoids during competition than during practice.
Figure 1: Anatomy of the medial ankle
Mechanism of injury
The medial ankle is fairly well protected by the fan of ligaments known collectively as the deltoid ligament; therefore it requires a large force to strain the medial structures (see figure 1). Studies show that the deltoid ligament may be injured more often than we think. Fifty participants in a Korean study underwent 3T Magnetic Resonance Imaging prior to ankle arthroscopy for lateral ankle sprains2. The MRI detected concurrent injury to the deltoid ligament in 36% of the patients. Other researchers report as many as 39% of studied ankle fractures also involved damage to the deltoid ligament1. Therefore, deltoid sprains and tears may get overlooked when treating more concerning injuries.
Knowing there may be an undetected concurrent sprain, evaluate medial stability in all ankle injuries, especially when an athlete demonstrates chronic instability. Deltoid ligament involvement requires particular consideration when planning rehabilitation and return to sport. Mallac outlines a progressive program to return to running as well as appropriate taping to decrease chances of re-injury (see figure 2). Most minor isolated deltoid sprains require little to no loss of time from sport – good news for athletes who suffer this uncommon injury!
Figure 2: Low-dye taping for medial stability
- J Ath Trng. 2017;52(4):350-59
- Jireab H /raduik, 2015;16(5):1096-1103