Don Hutchison holds his shoulder in pain 2001. REUTERS/Ian Hodgson
In 2018 Jeremy Lewis, Ph.D. raised a controversial point in his editorial titled The End of an Era?(1) He proposed that surgery for subacromial pain may be unnecessary as the acromion may not impinge structures as once believed. He also presents physical therapy and exercise for shoulder pain as an equally effective strategy. He makes an interesting recommendation that
“… although manual therapy may only have a short-term effect and provide no difference in functional outcome measurements…its addition might improve patient-perceived success at 4 weeks and 6 months, and acceptability of symptoms at 4 weeks.”(1)
Dr. Lewis asserts that manual therapy, indeed surgery itself, may be a placebo treatment, yet also a completely acceptable addition to a treatment plan. Researchers in Connecticut investigated whether upper thoracic spinal manipulations might indeed be a beneficial, rather than a placebo, component in the treatment of shoulder pain(2). They enrolled 60 recreationally active adults, ages 18-65, with shoulder pain in the study and randomly assigned them to one of three groups:
Supine thoracic spine thrust manipulation (TSTM)
Seated TSTM
Sham manipulation
All subjects tested positively for at least three signs of subacromial pain:
+ Pain with isometric resisted abduction or external rotation
The researchers administered the following baseline measurements to all participants:
Penn Shoulder Score
Scapular upward rotation and posterior tilt during both AROM and PROM of the shoulder
Pectoralis minor muscle length
Peak isometric force of middle and lower trapezius and serratus anterior
The examiner was blinded to the assignment of the subject when administering the baseline test, but not when conducting the same tests post-intervention.
After the baseline assessment, the subjects received one of the three treatment interventions to the spine between the levels of C7 and T4, two times during one treatment session. Immediately after the treatment, the same baseline tests were given except for the Penn Shoulder Score, which was administered 48 hours after the intervention.
Results
The researchers reported the change in scores for the tests from baseline to post-intervention for all three interventions and compared them. The results showed no significant difference in the change in score between the three interventions. Nor do the investigators report a significant change in score within a treatment approach. While they offer many reasons why their hypothesis that the TSTM would positively impact one of the measured outcomes was possibly not proven, the reasoning seems a bit far-fetched. For instance, they assert that only 20% of the subjects were interested in receiving treatment for their shoulder pain. This implies that perhaps the participants didn’t have significant enough pain or dysfunction. Yet, they each had to test positively for three diagnostic conditions. Indeed even the sham test failed to produce “patient perceived success,” as Dr. Lewis wistfully suggests(1). While disappointing to the investigators, this well-conducted study seems to conclude that TSTM does not affect scapular movement, position, or subacromial pain. Therefore, it has no place in the evidence-based treatment of this condition.
Anterior cruciate ligament injuries remain one of the most common sports injuries(1). While sports injury science has made strides toward understanding the causes of injury and prevention strategies, many young athletes still suffer from ACL tears and ruptures. In 2019, sports professionals from various disciplines gathered in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to reach a consensus on the... MORE
Athletes with persistent and undiagnosed shoulder pain may suffer from the rare but painful quadrilateral space syndrome. Chris Mallac unravels this complex diagnosis and offers practical treatment solutions. Quadrilateral Space Syndrome (QSS), first described in 1983, is a rare and unusual shoulder pathology primarily seen in male volleyballers, swimmers, and baseball pitchers(1,2). Athletes with QSS... MORE
Paper Title: A Secondary Injury Prevention Program May Decrease Contralateral Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries in Female Athletes: 2-Year Injury Rates in the ACL-SPORTS Randomized Controlled Trial Publication: J Orthop Sports Phys Ther.2020 Sep;50(9):523-530. doi: 10.2519/jospt.2020.9407. Publication Date: Epub 2020 Aug 1 INTRODUCTION: Rehab of athletes after ACL reconstruction surgery (ACL-r) often includes quad strengthening, plyometrics,... MORE
Gluteus medius (GMed)weakness gets blamed for all manner of lower extremity injuries. This broad muscle lies under the gluteus maximus, arises from the ilium’s posterior portion and spans from the iliac crest to the sciatic notch, and attaches on the greater trochanter of the femur. The muscle spreads out like a fan and has three... MORE
There are two reasons why clinicians should consider rehabilitating athletes differently than other individuals. Firstly, athletes are already highly trained with muscular adaptations for their sport. Secondly, they desire to return to a level of performance beyond community-based activity. Therefore, they start with a baseline of strength beyond most individuals, and they need to return... MORE
Part one of this two-part series on Pectoralis Major (PM) tendon ruptures discussed the mechanism of injury, signs, and symptoms of a ruptured PM tendon, and the resulting functional limitations. In part two, Chris Mallac explains the management of this condition and describes the post-operative rehabilitation protocol. Most practitioners recommend surgical repair for PM ruptures,... MORE