The sports medicine industry is lately taking a hard look at the reliance on imaging for diagnosis, as well they should. Diagnostic imaging has become a multi-billion dollar industry in the United States(1). The dependence on imaging for clinical decision making decreases the amount of time the practitioners spend with patients and possibly the number of referrals for conservative management.
As discussed in a recent newsletter, two-thirds of the knees in asymptomatic middle-aged runners show evidence of some sort of pathology on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)(2). This ‘damage’ existed before the previously sedentary subjects even started training for a marathon. Oddly enough, the images taken after completing the training and the subsequent race weren’t significantly worse than the pre-training images; some even showed improvement.
A multi-center systematic review and meta-analysis seems to point toward the same conclusions. This study looked for evidence of osteoarthritis (OA) on MRIs of asymptomatic adult knees(1). They evaluated 46 cross-sectional and 17 longitudinal studies with a total of 5397 knees. The investigators found that the incidence of OA increased substantially in subjects over 40 years old and, therefore, reported the results in an under and over 40 years of age format (see table 1).
Table 1: Incidence of osteoarthritis in asymptomatic knees
Degenerative change
Incidence in population < 40 years old
Incidence in population ≥ 40 years old
Is increase in ≥ 40 population significant?
Notes
Articular cartilage defect
11%
43%
Yes
Occurred more often in women.
Meniscal tears
4%
19%
Yes
Occurred more often in women.
Medial tears significantly more common than lateral.
Bone marrow lesions
14%
21%
No
Not associated with gender.
Higher incidence in <40 year old former weight bearing athletes.
Osteophytes
8%
37%
Yes
Not associated with gender
This systemic review showed that degenerative changes in the knee are present in nearly half of the asymptomatic population over 40-years-old. It also revealed that former weight-bearing athletes under 40 have a higher incidence of bone marrow lesions, yet they don’t complain of knee pain. Therefore, when clinicians recommend procedures based on MRI reports, they run the risk of having identified a red herring. As these studies show, evidence of OA in the knee does not necessarily correlate with symptomology. Could it be that weakness, inactivity, overweight, or inflammation from another source is the cause of the pain? Another possible trigger is under or overloading the joint.
So why the reliance on imaging? When did practitioners begin to doubt their clinical skills and judgment? At least in the United States, it was likely when insurance companies wanted proof. Imaging studies are ordered to validate medical diagnosis and decision making. However, they have not significantly improved the treatment outcomes in those with knee pain(1).
It’s time to return to sound clinical skills and the utilization of basic exercise physiology. While joint deterioration doesn’t always cause symptoms, a patient can’t un-see an MRI. Does seeing an image of cartilage damage and hearing the descriptor ‘bone on bone’ make a knee more symptomatic? More research needs to determine if knowing MRI results changes the outcomes of treatment choices and conservative management.
Paper title: Patellofemoral joint loading during the forward and backward lunge Publication: Physical Therapy in Sport. Jan 2021; Vol. 47, Pages 178-184 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ptsp.2020.12.001 Publication date: Jan 2021 INTRODUCTION Patellofemoral pain syndrome (PFPS) is one of the most common causes of knee pain in young athletes. It usually presents as anterior and retro-patellar knee pain made... MORE
Part one of this article series discussed the patho-anatomy of thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) and the typical symptoms associated with the different neurological and vascular TOS subtypes. In part two, Chris Mallac outlines the clinical tests used to diagnose TOS and discusses conservative management and surgical options to treat this injury. Clinical Tests There are... MORE
As we close out the month of May and our dive into sports injury in female athletes, we highlight a study that points out just how little research focuses on female ACL injuries. Researchers in Italy found only one recent video analysis study of ACL injuries in soccer players that included female athletes(1). They note... MORE
Paper Title: Menstrual Irregularity, Hormonal Contraceptive Use, and Bone Stress Injuries in Collegiate Female Athletes in the United States. Publication: PM&R Publication date: Published online ahead of print on 2020 Dec 19.doi: 10.1002/pmrj.12539. INTRODUCTION For many women, the symptoms of menstruation or menstrual irregularity (MI) can get in the way of athletic performance. Therefore, some choose... MORE
Female athletes use resistance training to enhance their strength and performance. The pelvic floor is perhaps the only region where physical exertion may create a negative effect. Tracy Ward examines the issue to determine if females are at risk of causing or worsening pelvic floor problems with weighttraining. Females have unique anatomy, biomechanics, and physiology... MORE
Female athletes with persistent musculoskeletal pain may suffer from joint hypermobility syndrome. Though often overlooked, it is associated with an increase in injuries and can significantly affect athletic abilities. Tracy Wardprovides an overview of the condition, its implications, and specific treatment strategies to enhance performance. Joint hypermobility syndrome (JHMS) is a connective tissue disorder that... MORE
