How did the assumption that running causes osteoarthritis get started? Perhaps from the thought that the when the foot hits the ground at a faster rate than walking, the body experiences greater forces at the joints. Maybe it came from the fact that when people first started running recreationally they found it difficult and therefore figured that if it feels harder then it must be harder on the body than walking. Then again, possibly the first generation of recreational runners experienced knee and hip pain and therefore theorized that it must be due to joint degeneration.
Whatever the origin, scientists have since sought to either verify or disprove this theory. As quoted in the newsletter examining knee osteoarthritis(OA) and running, a literature review by Spanish researchers found little proof that recreational running contributed to osteoarthritis in either the knee or the hip(1). In fact, among subjects studied, recreational runners had the lowest incidence of OA (3.5%) when compared to sedentary subjects (10.2%) or elite competitive runners (13.3%).
Running, except at the most elite levels of more than 92 km per week, may actually have a protective effect on the hip joints(2). Researchers at the University of Melbourne and La Trobe University suspected the load experienced by the hip joints when running was less than when walking(3). To investigate this, they recruited eight subjects and evaluated their walking and running at varying speeds.
Using a three-dimensional model, they calculated the contact forces at the hip joint made by the gluteus medius, iliopsoas, gluteus maximus, and hamstrings during each speed. They then determined the total loads at the joint along with the per unit distance (PUD) load – meaning the load encountered for a total stride distance. While the total hip contact force (HCF) experienced during running was greater than walking, the PUD force during running was equal to or less than that of walking. Therefore, running may actually preserve the integrity of the hip joint over walking.
The authors acknowledge that these results are applicable to recreational levels of running only. At elite distances, even the decreased PUD experienced in running may be enough to cause cumulative damage. In addition, they site the computer modeling as a potential limitation of this study; although in vivo measurements typically only take place after total hip replacements in elderly patients, and therefore may not accurately represent the function of healthy joints.
Whether looking at hip joint contact forces or incidence of OA in runners, the evidence shows that recreational running not only preserves the integrity of the hip joint, it may even protect it from further degeneration.
Paper title: Assessing the differences in muscle stiffness measured with shear wave elastography and myotonometer during the menstrual cycle in young women Publication: Clinical Physiology and Functional Imaging Publication date: May 2022 INTRODUCTION One of the most important factors in maintaining dynamic knee stability is muscle stiffness, which is proportional to muscle fiber recruitment and... MORE
An injury will, directly and indirectly, affect the entire kinetic chain. Therefore, practitioners should develop holistic clinical assessment and rehabilitation plans. Cameron Gill reviews the complex interplay between the hamstring injury and ACL rupture risk to aid clinical judgment and decision making. Over his first eight seasons, NBA sharpshooter Klay Thompson never missed more than... MORE
An acute hamstring injury is the most common muscle injury involving high-speed running in sports. The financial, physical, and psychological burden on athletes and teams is significant. Furthermore, the reinjury rate is high. Therefore, effective hamstring injury rehabilitation is essential to reduce the risks and optimize individual and team performance. Researchers at the Copenhagen University... MORE
Tennis – Australian Open – Women’s Doubles Final – Czech Republic’s Barbora Krejcikova and Katerina Siniakova celebrate with the trophy after winning their final match against Kazakhstan’s Anna Danilina and Brazil’s Beatriz Haddad Maia REUTERS/Morgan Sette Paper Title: The relationship between Landing Error Scoring System performance and injury in female collegiate athletes Publication: International Journal... MORE
There is an undisputed role for exercise in the early rehabilitative phase of soft tissue injuries. However, exercise prescription remains a challenge. In this article, Eurico Marques provides a framework for creating an individualized exercise prescription – the so-called ‘sweet spot.’ Skeletal muscle injuries occur when an external force overwhelms the muscle’s ability to generate... MORE
Paper Title: Deceleration Training in Team Sports: Another Potential ‘Vaccine’ for Sports-Related Injury Publication: Sports Med Publication date: October 2021 INTRODUCTION Sprinting improves performance and reduces the risk of injury. Deceleration precedes a change of direction (COD) and reduces momentum when slowing down while running. High-intensity deceleration occurs more often than acceleration in team sports,... MORE